The best restaurants in Brooklyn, according to critics

47 Brooklyn, NY restaurants featured on published critics’ lists from 5 publications: Eater NY, James Beard Foundation, MICHELIN Guide, The New York Times, The World's 50 Best Restaurants. Ordered by how many of those lists agree.

• Aska — Williamsburg, Brooklyn — on 3 critics’ lists
• The Four Horsemen — Williamsburg, Brooklyn — on 3 critics’ lists
• A&A Bake and Doubles — Bedford-Stuyvesant, Brooklyn — on 2 critics’ lists
• Lilia — Williamsburg, Brooklyn — on 2 critics’ lists
• Yemenat — Bay Ridge, Brooklyn — on 2 critics’ lists
• A&A Bake Doubles and Roti — Bedford-Stuyvesant, Brooklyn
• Agi's Counter — Crown Heights, Brooklyn
• Al Badawi — Brooklyn Heights, Brooklyn
• Alta Calidad — Prospect Heights, Brooklyn
• Bong — Crown Heights, Brooklyn
• Bonnie's — Williamsburg, Brooklyn
• Café Mars — Gowanus, Brooklyn
• Cas West Indian & American Restaurant — Crown Heights, Brooklyn
• Chavela's — Crown Heights, Brooklyn
• Chuan Tian Xia — Sunset Park, Brooklyn
• Eyval — Bushwick, Brooklyn
• Francie — Williamsburg, Brooklyn
• Gordo's Cantina — Bushwick, Brooklyn
• Haenyeo — Park Slope, Brooklyn
• Hometown Bar B Que New York — Red Hook, Brooklyn
• L’Industrie Pizzeria — Williamsburg, Brooklyn
• Laghman Express — Bensonhurst, Brooklyn
• LORE — Park Slope, Brooklyn
• Miss Ada — Fort Greene, Brooklyn
• Olmo — Bedford-Stuyvesant, Brooklyn
• Oxomoco — Greenpoint, Brooklyn
• Peter Luger Steak House — Williamsburg, Brooklyn
• Pierozek — Greenpoint, Brooklyn
• Randazzo's Clam Bar — Sheepshead Bay, Brooklyn
• Red Hook Tavern — Red Hook, Brooklyn
• Restaurant Yuu — Greenpoint, Brooklyn
• Roberta's — Bushwick, Brooklyn
• Roman's — Fort Greene, Brooklyn
• Runner Up — Park Slope, Brooklyn
• Sahadi's — Cobble Hill, Brooklyn
• Sal Tang's — Carroll Gardens, Brooklyn
• Shalom Japan — Williamsburg, Brooklyn
• Shota Omakase — Williamsburg, Brooklyn
• Sobre Masa — Bushwick, Brooklyn
• Sofreh — Prospect Heights, Brooklyn
• Speedy Romeo — Clinton Hill, Brooklyn
• Tanoreen — Bay Ridge, Brooklyn
• Taqueria El Chato — Greenpoint, Brooklyn
• Toné Cafe — Brighton Beach, Brooklyn
• Totonno's — Coney Island, Brooklyn
• Untable — Carroll Gardens, Brooklyn
• Win Son — East Williamsburg, Brooklyn

The Brooklyn lists

• The 38 Best Restaurants in New York City — Eater NY
• James Beard America's Classics Award Winners (1998–2026) — James Beard Foundation
• MICHELIN Bib Gourmand — New York 2025 — MICHELIN Guide
• MICHELIN Guide New York — Starred Restaurants 2025 — MICHELIN Guide
• The 100 Best Restaurants in New York City, 2026 — The New York Times
• North America's 50 Best Restaurants 2026 — The World's 50 Best Restaurants

The Critic List — the critics’ “best restaurants” lists, in one place. We don’t write the lists; the critics do, and every one links back to the original.