The best restaurants in Indianapolis, according to critics
19 Indianapolis, IN restaurants featured on published critics’ lists from 2 publications: Indianapolis Monthly, James Beard Foundation. Ordered by how many of those lists agree.
- St. Elmo Steak House — Downtown, Indianapolis — on 2 critics’ lists
- Bluebeard — Fletcher Place, Indianapolis
- Borage — Speedway, Indianapolis
- Brozinni Pizzeria — Southport, Indianapolis
- Che Chori — Haughville, Indianapolis
- Cheeky Bastards — Lawrence, Indianapolis
- Corridor — South Broad Ripple, Indianapolis
- Fernando's Mexican & Brazilian Cuisine — Broad Ripple, Indianapolis
- Julieta Taco Shop — Old Northside, Indianapolis
- Late Harvest Kitchen — North Side, Indianapolis
- Macizo Restaurant — Indianapolis
- Magdalena — Fountain Square, Indianapolis
- Milktooth — Fletcher Place, Indianapolis
- Oakleys Bistro — North Side, Indianapolis
- Shoyu Shop at Strange Bird — Irvington, Indianapolis
- The Flatiron — Downtown, Indianapolis
- Tinker Street Restaurant & Wine Bar — Herron-Morton Place, Indianapolis
- Vida — Downtown, Indianapolis
- Wisanggeni Pawon — Glendale, Indianapolis
The Indianapolis lists
The Critic List — the critics’ “best restaurants” lists, in one place. We don’t write the lists; the critics do, and every one links back to the original.