Pilgrim's Inn

$$$ · New American, Seafood restaurant in Deer Isle.

20 Main St

Seasonal à la carte menus of local Maine seafood and produce in a 1793 inn.

Cuisine: New American, Seafood

Featured on 1 list

• The Restaurant List 2025 — The New York Times (2025) · read the original

The Critic List — the critics’ “best restaurants” lists, in one place. We don’t write the lists; the critics do, and every one links back to the original.